Haydn, Franz Joseph : Sonate für Klavier Nr.43 Mov.2 Menuet
Work Overview
Genre:sonata
Total Playing Time:3 min 30 sec
Copyright:Public Domain
Commentary (1)
Author : Ooi, Kazurou
Last Updated: March 5, 2025
[Open]
Author : Ooi, Kazurou
This discussion concerns the opening of the Minuet. If the very first sixteenth note E-flat was composed with the premise that the turn should be played after it emerges from the off-beat of the second beat, then the execution would be EsFEsDEsGB. However, a point of discussion arises as to whether the composer intended this initial E-flat to be repeated, thus sounding as EsEsFEsDEsGB. While a counter-argument might suggest "there is insufficient time for such an execution," the crux of the matter lies in the intended atmosphere and mood of this Minuet. While one could simply establish a tempo that accommodates sufficient time even with the repetition of E-flat, the fundamental point remains the comprehension of the piece, irrespective of whether E-flat is repeated. There is no definitive right or wrong interpretation; however, one approach involves rendering the turn indicated at the outset in a melodic fashion. Furthermore, an alternative approach suggests avoiding mechanical execution, instead shaping even the turns with abundant lyricism and performing them smoothly. Similarly, the triplets in the third measure should descend smoothly, akin to a vocal line. While the Trio possesses a serious dimension, it too can benefit from an inherent lyrical quality. Thus, one can conceptualize this entire second movement as a song, and interpret the Minuet and Trio as a contrast between their distinct facets. By adopting this perspective, the tempo might become slightly slower; however, by conceiving the piece as an aria from an opera, the music undergoes a profound transformation. For your consideration.