Chopin, Frederic : Barcarolle Fis-Dur Op.60
Work Overview
Publication Year:1846
First Publisher:Leipzig, Paris and London
Dedicated to:Baronne de Stockhausen
Instrumentation:Piano Solo
Genre:barcarolle
Total Playing Time:9 min 30 sec
Copyright:Public Domain
Commentary (2)
Author : Asayama, Natsuko
Last Updated: July 1, 2008
[Open]
Author : Asayama, Natsuko
The "Barcarolle" is said to originate from the songs of Venetian gondoliers. Characterized by a light movement in 6/8 time, a common feature of many "Barcarolles" is their underlying sentimentality or melancholy. However, it is almost impossible to trace its tradition as a genre. Its popularity likely began with the favored use of this type of song in 19th-century operas. As for works for piano, Mendelssohn left three pieces, including those in his Songs Without Words, while Chopin's is the largest in scale and the finest masterpiece. Furthermore, Fauré wrote 13 pieces, suggesting he approached the "Barcarolle" as a genre. However, since then, works in this form have remained sporadic. Rather than a genre, the "Barcarolle" should be considered one of the character pieces that enjoyed long popularity from the mid-19th to the 20th century.
Chopin's Barcarolle
Chopin's Barcarolle, at first glance, sounds as if the opening theme repeatedly appears in a rondo-like fashion, with various episodes inserted in between. Therefore, a programmatic interpretation depicting a boat tour through the streets of Venice—for instance, the recurring theme corresponding to the scenery of the "Grand Canal"—is also possible. However, the Barcarolle actually possesses a well-structured form among Chopin's works, and features exquisitely elaborate thematic development.
Each section can be divided as follows:
Measure No. | Section | Key |
1-3 | Introduction | F-sharp major: Tonic |
|
|
|
4-16 | First Theme | F-sharp major: Tonic |
17-23 | Interlude |
|
24-34 | First Theme (Confirmation) |
|
|
|
|
35-39 | Interlude | F-sharp to A major: From tonic to mediant major of the parallel minor |
|
|
|
40-50 | Second Theme (first half) | A major/f-sharp minor |
51-61 | Second Theme (first half) (Confirmation) |
|
62-71 | Second Theme (second half) | A major |
|
|
|
72-77 | Interlude | C-sharp major: Dominant |
78-83 | Insertion |
|
|
|
|
84-92 | First Theme (Recapitulation) | F-sharp major: Tonic |
93-102 | Second Theme (second half) (Recapitulation) |
|
103-110 | Second Theme (first half) (Recapitulation) |
|
111-116 | Coda |
|
In other words, it is a type of ternary form most frequently used by Chopin, featuring the exposition of multiple themes, a brilliant passage-work middle section, and a recapitulation of themes. However, in this work, the middle section is significantly condensed, and instead of simple repetitions relying on beautiful melodies, skillful thematic arrangements are employed.
The first theme and the first half of the second theme are disturbed by a continuous 6/8 ostinato rhythm, yet their musical content is highly contrasting. The key shifts, incorporating the parallel minor. Furthermore, while the first theme is a descending melody, the first half of the second theme is ascending. The second half of the second theme has no clear connection with the first half other than its key. The brilliance of this theme is still subdued by the dynamics here.
In the middle section, though only five measures long, the 6/8 pulse momentarily ceases, leading to a free flow of time that transcends metrical rhythm. However, this section merely serves to make the listener aware of a different temporal flow, and does not present the characteristic melodic beauty of Chopin's middle sections.
The recapitulation begins with a variation of the first theme, culminates in a momentary rest, concludes with a perfect cadence, and then plunges into the second half of the second theme, remaining in the tonic key. The subsequent recapitulation of the first half of the second theme uses only its latter phrase, occasionally hinting at the sound of the parallel minor, and guides the grand narrative towards its conclusion. This is already the realm of the coda, where the magnificent arpeggiated motive of the second half of the second theme forms the climax, and the multi-layered, descending motive of the latter phrase of the first half brings it to a close. Such use of motives is truly nothing short of brilliant.
Viewed in this way, Chopin's Barcarolle, unlike Fauré's, is not so much lyrical music as it is narrative music, akin to his Scherzos or Ballades, employing a quasi-sonata form. However, what prevents it from falling into a rigid scheme is the skillful "transitions." The three measures of the introduction, the interlude at measures 35-39, and the double-note trills announcing the beginning of each section, precisely because they are largely unrelated to the overall thematic development, capture the listener's ear in just a few measures and dramatically change the musical atmosphere. The whole flows naturally, sounding as if it were a mere succession of ideas, or even lyrical. This work is indeed worthy of being called one of the greatest masterpieces of Chopin's late period, brilliantly fusing narrative and lyricism.
Author : Ooi, Kazurou
Last Updated: March 12, 2018
[Open]
Author : Ooi, Kazurou
Practice Tips
It might be more accurate to call these practice tips rather than performance tips. What is required when practicing this piece is “patience.” Some readers may find that their progress, despite diligent practice, is exceptionally slow compared to other pieces. Rest assured, the author shares this experience. This piece is very challenging, requiring not only efficient practice methods but also the patience to repeatedly accustom oneself to its demands.
Opening Measures and Polyphony
First, issues arise from the opening three measures. Simply get accustomed to them. Once you are somewhat accustomed, when playing the C# octave on the first beat of measure 1, ensure the 5th finger of your left hand produces a resonant, sustained, and deep bass note. Treat this C# with such care that its resonance lingers for three measures.Now, one characteristic of this piece is that Chopin fully demonstrates his masterful polyphonic skill. The texture is dense, and many sections are written in multiple voices. In the opening three measures, too, distinguish between the melodic line and non-melodic lines to avoid confusion. For example, in measure 1, what the author often hears is G#, E#, C#, F#, G#. However, in reality, it is only the three notes G#, F#, G#. Subdue the inner voices. Furthermore, apply ample rubato and play it as a free cadenza.
The “Peculiarity” of Stress on the Second Beat
A “peculiarity” of this piece is that the stress falls on the second beat. In measure 1, too, the second beat is where the tension is highest. Similarly, the melodic line starting from measure 6 also begins on the second beat. And the first beat signifies “the end of the previous phrase.” Therefore, an accent on the first beat is forbidden. For example, in measure 8, the first beat is the last note of measure 7, so play it as if it’s fading away. Then, a new phrase begins from the second beat. Please consider all subsequent patterns of this kind in the same way.
Advice on Phrasing the Theme
Advice regarding the theme. Let’s take measures 6-8 as an example. The phrase starting from the second beat of measure 6 ends on the first beat of measure 8. Looking closely at the line, it begins on C#, reaches the highest note, F#, in measure 7, then descends, becoming p in measure 8. From here, it’s up to individual interpretation, but the author would not give much volume to the F# in measure 7. Instead, crescendo through the subsequent A#, D#, C#, F#, B, making this the loudest part of the phrase, and upon reaching the final A# with a diminuendo, further diminuendo the descending inner voices to arrive at the final chord of measure 8.Let’s take just one more example. The next phrase begins on the second beat of measure 8 and ends on the first beat of measure 10. Similarly, reach the highest note, B, in measure 9 softly, and then, the non-harmonic tones such as G## on the second beat create a truly sensual, emotional, and poignant chord, so increase the tension there. Then, like the previous phrase, reach the A# on the fourth beat with a diminuendo, and do not make the first beat of measure 10 too loud.These phrasings are merely the author’s interpretations, so it is not mandatory to play them exactly this way. It is hoped that they will serve as a reference.
Measure 11: Sudden Color Change and Left Hand Technique
In measure 11, on the fourth beat, the color suddenly changes. Introduce a sudden change in timbre. The left hand in measures 11-12 is also difficult to play, isn’t it? Take the middle note of the arpeggiated chord, C#, with the 3rd finger of the left hand, and if you keep this 3rd finger on C# during both practice and performance, you can ensure a more secure location. In other words, rely on the 3rd finger to memorize the positions of the other notes.
Sixteenth-Note Sixths (Measure 14 onwards)
The six sixteenth-note sixths appearing from measure 14 recur frequently later in the piece. This is also a characteristic motif of this piece. However, these are quite difficult to play. The author would practice them in pairs. For example, in measure 15, the first pair on the second beat is F# D# and D# B#. First, practice only these two. Once you can play them, move on to the next two, and then the next two, and so on; this is a good way to practice. If practicing all six sixteenth notes together doesn’t work well, this approach is recommended.Another helpful tip is that there are places where these sixth units become octaves. For example, the last right-hand note in measure 14. Going from a sixth directly to an octave is challenging. Therefore, when an octave appears in this pattern, take the lower note of that octave with the left hand. This makes it considerably easier to play.
Repetitive Patterns and Rallentando (Measure 34)
Sections where the same chord and pattern repeat multiple times, as in measure 34, are often found in this piece. Perhaps this depicts a boat repeatedly swaying on waves, like on a lake. In any case, do not play them mechanically the same way; introduce variations. From the second beat of measure 34, “rall.” is indicated. So, follow it, but there’s a small trick at that time. Gradually increase the interval between the ornamental notes in both hands on beats 2-4 and the main notes as the music progresses. This creates a sense of fading away.
Ascending Sixteenth Notes (Measure 42)
The ascending sixteenth-note figure in the right hand appearing on the first beat of measure 42 is yet another motif. This figure serves a resonance role, so never play it strongly; instead, use the soft pedal or similar means to create an otherworldly sound quality. Subsequently, play all instances of this pattern with the same treatment.
The Final Pages
In any case, the last three pages are truly challenging. Believe strongly that you will eventually be able to play them, and practice patiently. The left hand is particularly important, so practice slowly and carefully to ensure your fingers fit firmly onto the chords.
Measure 107: Climax and Fingering
Please look at measure 107, first beat. This is where a climax reaches its goal. In such places, one might want to express strongly with forte, but the right-hand arpeggio is a difficult chord with notes more than an octave apart, and the 5th finger, which plays the last note, is on a black key. While white keys might be manageable, black keys are narrower, making mis-touches more likely. This is a place where you want to avoid mis-touches. In such a situation, instead of taking the highest note, G#, with the 5th finger, taking it with the 1st finger is safer and allows for a louder sound. From the bottom, take with 1, 2, 3, then instead of going to 5, play G# again with 1. Please try this.
PTNA & Partner Channel Videos(13items) View More
- favorite_border
- 0
Recording Date: 2021/7/31
Recording Location: 上野学園石橋メモリアルホール(2021年ピティナ・ピアノコンペティション 特級 二次予選)
Recording Date: 2023/8/19
Recording Location: 第一生命ホール(2023年ピティナ・ピアノコンペティション G級全国決勝大会)
Reference Videos & Audition Selections(8items)
Sheet Music
Scores List (8)

(株)春秋社

(株)全音楽譜出版社

(株)ドレミ楽譜出版社

(株)全音楽譜出版社

(株)全音楽譜出版社

ハンナ(ショパン)

(株)ヤマハミュージックエンタテインメントホールディングス

Peters